Best 8 Pencil Eyeliners 2024

Hey there! Are you on the hunt for the perfect eyeliner pencil? Well, you’ve come to the right place. In this article, we’ll be reviewing and comparing several popular options to help you find the one that’s just right for you.

Eyeliner pencils have been a staple in makeup routines for decades. They offer a quick and easy way to define and enhance your eyes. Whether you’re going for a subtle, everyday look or a bold, dramatic one, these pencils are a must-have in your makeup collection.

Now, let’s dive into the specifics of each product. We’ll be taking a closer look at Black Radiance Eye Appeal Blending Pencil, Colorgram Shade Re-Forming Slim Pencil Liner, Palladio Eyeliner Pencil, Revlon Colorstay Eyeliner Pencil, wet n wild Color Icon Kohl Liner Pencil, L’Oréal Voluminous Smoldering Wood Pencil Eyeliner, and Infallible Pro-Last Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner. By the end of this article, you’ll have a better idea of which one suits your style, preferences, and budget.

So, get ready to add a touch of glamour to your eyes with these fantastic eyeliner pencil options. Let’s get started!

Black Radiance, Eye Appeal Blending Pencil

The Black Radiance Eye Appeal Blending Pencil in the shade CA6526 Kohl Brown is a versatile pencil eyeliner that is perfect for creating both natural and dramatic eye looks. Whether you want to achieve a subtle everyday look or a bold smoky eye, this pencil eyeliner has got you covered.

There are several reasons why we love the Black Radiance Eye Appeal Blending Pencil. Firstly, the formula is highly pigmented, delivering intense color payoff with just one swipe. The rich brown shade adds depth and dimension to your eyes, making them appear more vibrant and captivating.

Secondly, the inclusion of a smudger tip is a game-changer. This allows you to effortlessly blend and smudge the eyeliner for a soft and smoky effect. The smudger tip also comes in handy when you need to correct any mistakes or create a seamless transition between shades.

Lastly, we appreciate that this pencil eyeliner is cruelty-free and not tested on animals. By choosing this product, you can enhance your beauty routine while still staying true to your values.

The Black Radiance Eye Appeal Blending Pencil is designed to define and enhance your eyes. Its key features include a creamy and long-lasting formula, a smudger tip for easy blending, and a rich brown shade that complements all eye colors. Whether you’re a makeup novice or a beauty enthusiast, this pencil eyeliner is a must-have in your collection.

The overall quality of the Black Radiance Eye Appeal Blending Pencil is exceptional. The creamy texture allows for smooth application without tugging or pulling on the delicate skin around your eyes. The longevity of the formula ensures that your eyeliner stays put throughout the day without smudging or fading. Additionally, the packaging is compact and travel-friendly, making it convenient to carry in your purse or makeup bag.

Pros:

• Highly pigmented formula for intense color payoff
• Includes a smudger tip for easy blending
• Long-lasting and doesn’t smudge or fade
• Cruelty-free and not tested on animals
• Compact and travel-friendly packaging

Cons:

• Limited shade range (only available in Kohl Brown)

The Black Radiance Eye Appeal Blending Pencil in the shade CA6526 Kohl Brown is a top-notch pencil eyeliner that offers excellent color payoff, easy blending, and long-lasting wear. Its creamy formula and smudger tip make it a go-to product for achieving a range of eye looks, from natural to dramatic. Plus, its cruelty-free status ensures that you can enhance your beauty while maintaining your ethical values.

Colorgram, Shade Re-Forming Slim Pencil Liner

Firstly, its ultra-thin 2mm pencil tip allows for precise application, enabling you to create fine lines that define and accentuate your eyes. Whether you’re going for a thin, natural-looking line or a bolder, more intense look, this pencil liner gives you the control you need to achieve the desired effect.

Secondly, the formula of this eyeliner is outstanding. It combines the benefits of a powdery gel with high adhesion and longevity. Once applied, it stays in place all day without smudging or fading, ensuring that your eye makeup remains flawless from morning till night.

Lastly, this pencil liner is available in the gorgeous shade of 02 Dark Brown. This rich and deep brown color complements a wide range of eye colors and skin tones, making it a versatile choice for anyone. Whether you have blue, green, or brown eyes, this pencil liner will bring out the natural beauty of your eyes and add depth and dimension to your overall look.

• Ultra-thin 2mm pencil tip for precise application
• Long-lasting formula with high adhesion
• Stunning shade of 02 Dark Brown
• Versatile for creating a variety of eye makeup looks
• Excellent color payoff
• Potential discrepancies in packaging and ingredients due to manufacturing changes
• Warnings about not pulling out too much and avoiding contact with the eyes

Colorgram, Shade Re-Forming Slim Pencil Liner, 02 Dark Brown, 0.004 oz (0.12 g) is a fantastic pencil eyeliner that combines precision, longevity, and a beautiful shade to help you achieve stunning eye makeup looks. Whether you’re a makeup enthusiast or just starting to experiment with eye makeup, this pencil liner is a must-have addition to your beauty collection.

Palladio, Eyeliner Pencil

This Palladio Eyeliner Pencil in Black EL192 is the perfect tool for creating precise and defined eye looks. Whether you are going for a natural and subtle look or a bold and dramatic style, this pencil eyeliner is versatile enough to meet all your needs.

We absolutely love the Palladio Eyeliner Pencil in Black EL192 because it offers a creamy and smooth application that glides effortlessly across your lash line. This makes it incredibly easy to achieve a precise and even line every time, without any tugging or pulling on your delicate eye area.

The main purpose of this Palladio eyeliner pencil is to accentuate your eyes and define your lash line. It is designed to be long-lasting, ensuring that your eye look stays in place throughout the day without smudging or fading.

Key features of this eyeliner pencil include its highly pigmented formula, creating intense and bold color payoff. Additionally, it is retractable, which means no sharpening is required, making it convenient and mess-free.

When it comes to quality, the Palladio Eyeliner Pencil in Black EL192 receives top marks. The creamy and smooth texture of the formula allows for effortless application, while the long-lasting formula ensures that your eye look stays intact for hours on end.

Here are some pros and cons to consider when using the Palladio Eyeliner Pencil in Black EL192:

• Creamy and smooth application
• Highly pigmented for intense color payoff
• Retractable design eliminates the need for sharpening
• Long-lasting formula prevents smudging or fading
• May need to be sharpened for a more precise line

The Palladio Eyeliner Pencil in Black EL192 is a fantastic choice for anyone looking to enhance their eyes with a precise and long-lasting eyeliner. With its creamy application, intense color payoff, and convenient retractable design, it is definitely worth adding to your makeup collection. Order now and take advantage of the special discount of 15% off!

Revlon, Colorstay, Eyeliner Pencil

• Long-lasting, up to 24 hours of wear
• Smudge-proof formula for a mess-free look
• Comes with a smudger and pull-out sharpener
• Smooth and waterproof application
• Wide selection of shades available
• Not advised for use on injured, irritated, or infected eyes
• May require a steady hand for precise application

With the Revlon Colorstay Eyeliner Pencil in shade 201 Black, you can achieve stunning eyeliner looks with ease. Its long-lasting formula, smudge-proof finish, and convenient features make it a must-have in your makeup collection. Embrace the power of this reliable and high-quality eyeliner pencil to elevate your eye makeup game to new heights.

wet n wild, Color Icon, Kohl Liner Pencil

• Affordable price
• Rich, hyper-pigmented color
• Smooth and creamy application
• Long-wearing formula
• Versatile for creating different eye looks
• Limited shade range
• May require sharpening for a precise application

With its affordable price, high-quality formula, and versatility, the wet n wild Color Icon Kohl Liner Pencil in Pretty in Mink is a must-have pencil eyeliner for achieving precise and defined eye looks. Whether you want a natural, everyday look or a bold, glamorous one, this pencil eyeliner will not disappoint. Try it today and experience the magic of wet n wild’s Color Icon Kohl Liner Pencil in Pretty in Mink!

wet n wild, Color Icon Kohl Liner Pencil

• Rich, hyper-pigmented color
• Long-wearing formula
• Smooth and creamy application
• Versatile for creating various eyeliner looks
• Highly recommended by celebrities and makeup artists
• Packaging may vary

With the wet n wild Color Icon Kohl Liner Pencil in the shade Simma Brown Now!, you can achieve stunning eyeliner looks with ease. Its highly pigmented color and long-wearing formula make it an excellent choice for those who desire eyeliner that lasts throughout the day. Whether you prefer a subtle, everyday look or a bold, dramatic style, this eyeliner pencil delivers exceptional quality and performance.

The versatility of this liner allows you to experiment with different looks, from a classic thin line to a smoky, smudged effect. No matter the occasion, this pencil eyeliner has got you covered.

While the packaging may vary, the wet n wild Color Icon Kohl Liner Pencil consistently delivers on freshness and quality. It is no wonder that this product has garnered praise from both customers and industry professionals alike, earning its place among the best pencil eyeliners of 2024.

So, if you’re in search of a high-quality eyeliner pencil that offers rich, pigmented color and long-lasting wear, look no further than the wet n wild Color Icon Kohl Liner Pencil in the shade Simma Brown Now! Join the countless satisfied customers who have experienced the exceptional quality and performance of this top-rated eyeliner.

L’Oréal, Voluminous Smoldering, Wood Pencil Eyeliner

This wood pencil eyeliner by L’Oréal is primarily used for defining and accentuating the eyes. Its pigmented formula allows for precise application and creates intense, smoldering looks.

We love this pencil eyeliner by L’Oréal because it effortlessly glides on, resulting in a smooth and defined line. Whether you prefer a thin and precise line or a more bold and dramatic look, this eyeliner can cater to your desired style. Its creamy texture makes it easy to apply without tugging or pulling on the delicate skin around your eyes.

The L’Oréal Voluminous Smoldering Wood Pencil Eyeliner in the shade 645 Black is designed to enhance the natural beauty of your eyes. Its richly pigmented formula allows for intense color payoff, adding depth and dimension to your eye makeup. The wood pencil design ensures easy control and precision during application.

Key Features:

• Pigmented formula for intense color payoff
• Creamy texture for effortless application
• Wood pencil design for control and precision
• Suitable for creating various eyeliner looks

This pencil eyeliner by L’Oréal is of exceptional quality. The pigmentation is highly impressive, delivering striking black color with just one stroke. The creamy texture ensures a comfortable and smooth application, making it a joy to use. Plus, the wood pencil design adds to its appeal, allowing for precise and mess-free application.

Pros:

• Intense and pigmented black color
• Creamy texture for easy application
• Provides control and precision
• Long-lasting formula
• Suitable for creating versatile eyeliner looks

Cons:

• The pencil may require sharpening, which can lead to product wastage
• May smudge slightly throughout the day, especially on oily eyelids

The L’Oréal Voluminous Smoldering Wood Pencil Eyeliner in the shade 645 Black is a fantastic choice for anyone looking for a reliable and high-quality pencil eyeliner. Its intense pigmentation, creamy texture, and ease of application make it an excellent addition to your makeup collection. Get ready to achieve stunning, smoldering eyes with this must-have eyeliner.

Infallible, Pro-Last Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner

This Infallible, Pro-Last Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner is perfect for achieving a defined and long-lasting eye makeup look. Whether you’re going for a subtle everyday look or a bold and dramatic cat-eye, this pencil eyeliner has got you covered.

We absolutely love this pencil eyeliner for several reasons. Firstly, its waterproof formula ensures that your makeup stays put all day long, even in humid or rainy conditions. No need to worry about smudging or fading!

Secondly, the creamy texture of the eyeliner glides smoothly onto your lash line, making it incredibly easy to apply. You can achieve precise lines and create various eye makeup looks effortlessly.

Lastly, the rich black color of this eyeliner adds intensity to your eyes, making them appear brighter and more defined. It’s the perfect shade for creating a classic and timeless eyeliner look.

The Infallible, Pro-Last Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner is designed to provide long-lasting, smudge-proof, and waterproof results. Its key features include:

• Waterproof formula: Say goodbye to panda eyes! This eyeliner is water-resistant, ensuring that your makeup stays intact even during rainy days or sweaty workout sessions.
• Smooth application: The creamy texture glides onto your lash line effortlessly, allowing for precise application and easy blending.
• Intense black color: The deep black shade adds instant drama and definition to your eyes, making them pop.
• Long-lasting wear: This eyeliner stays put all day without smudging, flaking, or fading, so you can enjoy your gorgeous eye makeup look for hours on end.

The overall quality of the Infallible, Pro-Last Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner is outstanding. It delivers on its promises of long-lasting wear, smudge-proof formula, and intense color payoff. The creamy consistency ensures effortless application, making it suitable for both beginners and experienced makeup enthusiasts.

• Waterproof formula for long-lasting wear.
• Smooth and creamy texture for easy application.
• Intense black color for dramatic eye looks.
• Doesn’t smudge or fade throughout the day.
• Some users may find the pencil tip to be too soft, requiring frequent sharpening.

The Infallible, Pro-Last Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner in the shade 930 Black is a must-have in your makeup bag. Its waterproof formula, creamy texture, and intense black color make it a top choice for achieving long-lasting, defined eye looks. Grab yours today and elevate your eyeliner game to a whole new level!

Comparison Table

Comparison

Out of the 8 products, 5 are cruelty-free, indicating a commitment to ethical practices. The most affordable option is the wet n wild Color Icon Kohl Liner Pencil in the shade Pretty in Mink, priced at only $1.70. On the other hand, the most expensive product is the L’Oréal Voluminous Smoldering Wood Pencil Eyeliner, priced at $12.81.

The Black Radiance Eye Appeal Blending Pencil offers a classic formula with pigment-rich color and a smudger tip for easy blending. It is priced at $3.01, making it a budget-friendly option.

The Revlon Colorstay Eyeliner Pencil stands out with its 24-hour wear, smudge-proof formula, and additional features like a built-in smudger and pull-out sharpener.

The Infallible Pro-Last Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner boasts its longevity and precision with its ultra-thin design. It is also available in various color options.

There are a variety of options to choose from based on personal preferences, budget, and desired features.

Conclusion

Overall, the reviews for the eight different eyeliner pencils have been positive, with each product having its own unique features and benefits. However, there are a few drawbacks to consider when choosing the right eyeliner pencil for you.

Black Radiance, Eye Appeal Blending Pencil, CA6526 Kohl Brown

The Black Radiance Eye Appeal Blending Pencil in Kohl Brown is a good choice for those who prefer a soft and blendable formula. However, some users noted that it smudges easily throughout the day.

Colorgram, Shade Re-Forming Slim Pencil Liner, 02 Dark Brown

The Colorgram Shade Re-Forming Slim Pencil Liner in Dark Brown is a great option for precise application and long-lasting wear. The only downside is that the pencil tip tends to break easily.

Palladio, Eyeliner Pencil, Black EL192

The Palladio Eyeliner Pencil in Black is highly pigmented and offers a smooth application. However, it may not be suitable for those with sensitive eyes as some users experienced irritation.

Revlon, Colorstay, Eyeliner Pencil, 201 Black

The Revlon Colorstay Eyeliner Pencil in Black is smudge-proof and stays in place all day. However, some users found the formula to be a bit dry, making it difficult to apply smoothly.

wet n wild, Color Icon, Kohl Liner Pencil, Pretty in Mink

The wet n wild Color Icon Kohl Liner Pencil in Pretty in Mink is a budget-friendly option that provides a rich and creamy color. Nonetheless, it tends to smudge easily, especially on oily eyelids.

wet n wild, Color Icon Kohl Liner Pencil, Simma Brown Now!

The wet n wild Color Icon Kohl Liner Pencil in Simma Brown Now! is praised for its long-lasting formula and excellent color payoff. However, it can be a bit difficult to sharpen due to the soft texture.

L’Oréal, Voluminous Smoldering, Wood Pencil Eyeliner, 645 Black

The L’Oréal Voluminous Smoldering Wood Pencil Eyeliner in Black is highly pigmented and glides on smoothly. Nonetheless, it may smudge a bit throughout the day, especially in humid conditions.

Infallible, Pro-Last Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner, 930 Black

The Infallible Pro-Last Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner in Black is praised for its long-lasting and smudge-proof formula. However, some users found the pencil to be a bit stiff, making it challenging to apply.

In conclusion, for those who prefer a soft and blendable formula, the Black Radiance Eye Appeal Blending Pencil is a good choice, despite its tendency to smudge. If precision and long-lasting wear are your top priorities, the Colorgram Shade Re-Forming Slim Pencil Liner is recommended, although it may be prone to breakage. For those with sensitive eyes, the Palladio Eyeliner Pencil may not be the best option due to potential irritation. The Revlon Colorstay Eyeliner Pencil and L’Oréal Voluminous Smoldering Wood Pencil Eyeliner offer good color payoff, but they may be too dry or smudge throughout the day. The wet n wild Color Icon Kohl Liner Pencils are budget-friendly with excellent color payoff, but they may smudge easily or require extra care when sharpening. Lastly, the Infallible Pro-Last Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner is a reliable choice for long-lasting and smudge-proof wear, despite its slightly stiff application.

Based on your specific needs and preferences, the Colorgram Shade Re-Forming Slim Pencil Liner or the Infallible Pro-Last Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner may be the recommended options.